We would like to incorporate our location, Brooklyn, New York in the logo. Very much like the vintage 1940s - 1960's baseball logos, particularly the circular shapes - pins and patches.
Remember, our site is pure nostalgia - people re-living their moments in these ballparks with their mom, dads grandpas etc. It's history tied to strong emotion for the past. I've included some images of logos that are cool, but honestly if you have a great idea that connects the dots that I mentioned above - nostalgia, history, family, baseball, ballparks - I'd love to see it! (I like patches too).
Here is a link to an old baseball hat page. You can kind of get an idea of the fonts that were popular then for baseball.
Our main goal is to have a logo that is cool enough that people will want to buy sweatshirts, hats etc. with it on it.